• YT

  yisroel t -2 שנים לִפנֵי

  bh 

  hoe would you tell this story to a thoughtful 5 yr old, who dosent get how miryam haniviyah spoke negatevly?

  thank you in advance!

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • Anonymous -1 שָׁנָה לִפנֵי

    I guess that she had questions about the shiduch, things she felt were not good for moshe

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• H

  Hillel -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Gut voch, I just finished listening to your shiur on why Miriam related to Ahron her wanting if Moshe to divorce Tziporah for the 4th time. It was tremendous! Really beautiful!

   

  I think it would be k’die to be moisif one last idea to your explanation al pi the Moishav Zekainim Mi’balai HaTosfos, in which you explained why Hkb”h said on Moshe, “V’chol bais’e ne’eman” perhaps with that in mind we understand why we wish each chosson and kallah to build a bay is NE’EMAN b’yisrael. Why if all things Ne’eman? With your explanation it’s clear. Each one is not serving G-d’s of others, e.g. what donthe neighbors say about our shidduch. Rather, each one is focused on hkbh and realize that their spouse is THE PATH to Hashem. So that’s the emphasis on Ne’eman. We are believing in Hashem giving me the partner I need to get closer to him, that’s my focus on my partner, not public opinion.

   

   

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • YR

    Yekesiel rosen -1 שָׁנָה לִפנֵי

    Beautiful!

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

    • Anonymous -1 שָׁנָה לִפנֵי

      thanks so so much

      השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• E

  Ephraim -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Dear Rabbi Jacobson,

  You mentioned in your previous shiur how it would have been inappropriate for Moshe Rabeinu to divorce tzippora after he ascended to gedula. You mentioned that she stuck with him before his greatness was acknowledged by the masses.  Her character was impeccable despite her yichus. You used this as a springboard to decry those whose requirements for a shidduch is begins with what someone else will think be it yichus, money prestige etc.

   

  I have a few questions regarding this. 

   

  1)  the Moshe Rabeinu comparison isn't equal. To ask Moshe Rabeinu to divorce his wife because of yichus is different than not entertaining a shidduch because of a lack of yichus. It may be more comparable to Rabi Akiva and Rochel. 

   

  We find gedolim in europe married into wealthy families so that they can remain in learning uninterrupted. I hardly doubt that they did our mossad investigations about her character. They didnt call the mechutanim nor did they ask for references. Yet the proposal of the shidduch came about because the gvir wanted to have talmid chacham son-in-law. Isn't there an expression in chazal that one should marry a bas talmid chacham.

   

  2) there are Torah sanctioned yichus discriminations. I'm a kohen. I'm not allowed to marry a convert, divorcee ... Baalei teshuva of today are not so simple. Despite there not being an accounting for most of klal yisroel this population has more of a rayusa. If the character matters most why am i restricted.

   

  I know you mentioned that there is place for yichus. When and where? When we categorize people into groups (even though i hate labels being given for sects of jews because it dismisses people as either fanatical or pushes people down to elevate themselves) for shidduchim helps identify similar values. I can't live on boro park because i dont wear a streimal nor can i live in lakewood because i am no longer learning full time. To put myself there would be unfair to myself and my kids. When someone tries to intigrates you can't force your way into a sect of society. I can't join a society who likes high quality wine if i  haven't tasted anything but Moscato dasti. I'm not advocating segregation but to certain extent it helps us identify with each other and share values. When someone tries to force their way in it most likely won't be the results they hoped for.

   

  Thank you,

   

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

    You raise great point and great questions. I will be brief.

     

    1. Point well taken. I was just using it as a springboard for the conversation.

     

    2. For the Talmid Chacham learning was critical, hence his search for financial security was in order for him to be able to continue learning for many years. But this was for unique people, who really belonged learning all day and night.

     

    3. A bas talmid chacham means a woman who grew up with Torah, and values of Torah, and the benefits on character are obvious. In that sense, too, Yichus is wonderful, but mainly because it can tell us about the groom or the bride. This is not meant to shift focus from character to family reputation and prestige. If the groom or bride are not superficial people, that can be terrible. When the marriage is based merely on family and reputation, rather than internal appreciation, respect and love, it can spell a disaster. 

     

    4. Generally, in past generations, people married very young, they grew up together, and there was very little time to focus on "issues." Life span was short, people worked all day and much of the night, and duty was far more the focus than leisure.

     

    5. Of course, sensitivity to the community is important to appreciate the values of the groom and the bride. One has to take all factors into consideration: family, community, yeshiva background, reputation, dress, looks. But the main purpose of all of this to figure out the one most important thing: Who is this person inside. Then we can make a sane and a sound decision. The problem is when we just put people in a group, and we do not appreciate their individual quality. 

     

    Sometimes, if a person comes from a particular community and family, we just focus on that, instead of on his internal personality, values, and behavior. that should never happen. 

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• N

  Nossy -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Something I was wondering about is how do many midrashim and other sources have different opinions about different stories in the Torah, for example what you were discussing about Moshe and Tzipora, so the differences between Rashi and the Moshav Zekainim, and for example with Asnas, most hold she was Dinas daughter, some hold she was an Egyptian who converted, so Im just wondering how all the differences work unless there was 2 of the same people, Or like Iyov with 9 opinions of who and when he lived.

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

    See Likkutei Sichos vol. 6, Parshas Terumah, how to approach these types of debates. Of course, in reality only one thing could have happened (at least the way we detect reality, from our perspective.) Yet, we still say that "these and these are the words of the living G-d" (Eiruvin 13b.) Because each view, even if it could not materialize in the most practical way, still contains a truth about the story that exists on some level (perhaps, in thought, emotion, subconscious).

     

    What is more, see ibid. yet a deeper interpretation, "these and these are the words of the living G-d," ultimately means that they are, deep down, saying the same thing.

     

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• L

  Liba -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  ​This class

   on “yichus” and giving proper Kovod to converts etc was extremely meaningful and tremendously inspirational.
  
  I was wondering if there’s any source to something I read many years ago on this topic, that Miriam actually discovered her brothers separation because she saw Tzipora in her tent without cosmetics (make-up)... this message was explained to give women chizuk in the importance and beauty in protecting their homes by beautifying themselves for their husbands at home and that EVEN Moshe Rabbeinu appreciated this...
  
  Is there any validity to this?

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• KG

  Kalman Goldshtein -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  I do not understand

  I do not understand the whole concept of the second wife, because Moshe must have been constantly in a state of ritual purity. Why would he need a second wife?

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

     

     

    Rabbi Yosef Ibn Kaspo says we would not know the reason for it. In his words, "is it because Tzeporah did not want him, or another reason we do not know."

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  An interesting point

  Just to add to understand even better why Miriam wanted Moshe to marry a מיוחסת:

  According to the Targum Yonoson, Eldad and Meidad were sons of Yocheved and Eltzofon. After Amram divorced Yocheved, she married Eltzofon and had 2 children, Eldad and Meidad. When Amram was willing to take her back, Eltzofon divorced her and Amram took her back.  So Moshe was the son of a divorcee who remarried, being a major פגם in his lineage. In fact, according to Rabbi Akiva, Moshe was a Mamzer. (Or at least he would have been one after Mattan Torah.)

  Therefore, it was important to Miriam that Moshe marry a מיוחסת to show that he was a 'kosher' Jew.

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• M

  moshe -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Basket Not Casket

   I wouldn't mention the mispronounciations from the Tuesday shiur, but one was hilarious. Yocheved put Moshe in a basket, not a casket. Other end of life. 

  It's grand finaLEE, not grand finaLL.

  Also: it's AWEthenticity, not OHthenticity.

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• Z

  Zeev -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  6 zchiros

  Could you elaborate the point of why it’s in the 6 zchirois?

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• Y

  Yossi -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Thank you very much for your wonderful lessons!
  My wife and I meet personally every week to hear your shiur on this week's parsha.
  
  Since we hear the lessons, the parsha is revived!

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• K

  Katz -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  "Daas Zkeinim"

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• B

  Binyomin -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Letter from Rambam

  where is the letter of the Rambam

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

    Right below the video there is a source sheet attached.

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Worship

  Like Robert Zimmerman (Bob Dylan) said:

  You got to serve somebody,

  Now it may be the devil

  Or it may be the Lord

  But you got to serve somebody!

  But on a more serious note, the phenomenon is not new and not unknown and has nothing to do with Yiddishkeit.

  Thank you as always Rabbi YY for an amazing shiur!

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• S

  Sara -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Moshe and Zippora

  I have so many questions. I think I understand all the different commentaries you presented in the shiur related to who the Cushite woman was or wasn't, Moshe's loyatly and devotion to Zippora and to G-d, and all the rest, but i have some more questions that are not totally related to these interpretations, but that are questions I got as I was listening and processing what you were saying.  Let's start with the commentary of Tosafot who say that Moshe didn't want to separate from Zippora for all the reasons you gave. I understand that Zippora was a Midianite, but did she ever convert to Judaism? She lived the Jewish life with Moshe and had his two sons, one of whom she circumcized if I remember correctly. If she did not convert officially, she did observe a Jewish way of thinking - no? Another related question, if Zippora wasn't considered Jewish or wasn't a convert, is part of this lesson saying that under certain circumstances it's ok to marry out of Judaism. I don't mean to say that you support intermarriage or anything like that, but if G-d consdiered Moshe so loyal, the most loyal of all people, and one of the reasons was his loyalty to Zippora, and if in fact G-d supported Moshe in this regard, I'm not sure exactly what to make of this. Your other examples in the shiur of the Rabbi who ended up acceptingi his daughter choice, the ger, as a husband was a story of someone converting to Judaism which is a little different than this situation.  The other question has to do with the interpretation that says Moshe did in fact marry a Cushite woman, someone other than Zippora. I'm assuming this second wife was not Jewish either, or was she? So I guess the bigger question and if there is a midrash or writing about it, please provide if possible, seems that the greatest prophet of all, G-d's most faithful servant married non Jews?

   

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• J

  Joseph -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  Question

   I just watched your shir on why Miriam wanted moshe to get divorced thank u very much it was very good!

  I didn't understand one thing, what's the difference between the peshat of the Rashbam and the peshat of reb Yosef ibin Kaspi?

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

    Rashi and many others understand the story to mean that they were upset about Moshe's separation from his wife. Even according to this, Moshe was separated, but nobody knew about. Not even his sister Miriam. Meaning it was all kept hidden, and they were still living together in the same tent.

    But the Moshav Zekanim understands the story literally: they were upset about the marriage itself. This is also the view of Reb Yosef Ibn Caspi, but he believes that this was a second Ethiopian woman who he married in addition to Tzipora, and Miriam and Aaron were upset about the second marriage.

    The Rashbam holds that they were addressing the woman Moshe married a long time ago, in Kush, when he escaped there, before he married to Tziporah in Midyan.
    
    See Nechama Leibowitz for the various perspectives: http://www.nechama.org.il/pages/632.html

     

     

     

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

• Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

  SOUND

  IT LOOKS LIKE SOMETHING IS WRONG WITH THE SOUND OF THIS SHIUR. NO VOICE AT ALL

  השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

  • Anonymous -6 שנים לִפנֵי

    Yes, sorry, it was fixed.

    השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

    • S

      Sara -6 שנים לִפנֵי

      I still can't hear it on the website, but it's okay in Youtube

      השיבו לתגובה זו.סמן את התגובה הזו.

Women's ​Behaaloscha Class

Rabbi YY Jacobson

• May 29, 2018
• |
• 15 Sivan 5778
• |
• 5322 צפיות

שיעורים קשורים

• 

  1 שעה 30 דקות

  Women's Class Parshas Behaaloscha

  The Dance Between Attachment and Authenticity In Relationships, Psychology & Spirituality

  Why Do Victims of Abuse Blame Themselves, Not the Perpetrator?

• 

  1 שעה 30 דקות

  Women's Behaaloscha Class

  If Her Father Spat in Her Face: Miriam and Her Parents

  The Inspiration of the Nation: Why Did Miriam Speak Against Moshe?

• 

  1 שעה 3 דקות

  Women's Class Behaaloscha

  Cuddled in My Mother's Arms

  An Enigmatic Law in the Talmud Helps Us Alleviate Anxiety

• 

  1 שעה 25 דקות

  Women's Behaaloscha Class

  Great People Reach for the Impossible

  Every Child Needs a Miriam to Watch Over Him

• 

  1 שעה 22 דקות

  Behaaloscha/Korach/Pinchas

  Who Influenced You Most In your Life?

  Rashi and Rambam Have No Power Over Me; But What Influence!

• 

  1 שעה 53 דקות

  Tzafnas Panaach Behaaloscha Class

  Like Children Running Away From School: The Rogatchover's Perspective

  As the World Broke, I Can’t See in One Letter the Whole Truth

• 

  Essay Behaaloscha

  Every Child Needs a Miriam

  A Single Gesture Toward a Baby Reverberates Throughout History

• 

  1 שעה 30 דקות

  Behaaloscha Class

  Why Moshe Asked to Die

  Giving Feedback to Those Who Changed Our Lives

• 

  1 שעה 58 דקות

  Pesach Sheni/Behaaloscha

  Seeing Through the Husk: Reb Meir & the Heretic

  Pesach Sheni and the Power of Teshuvah

• 

  Essay Behaaloscha

  How to Deal with Economic Challenge

  The "days" and "nights" of life

• 

  54 דקות

  Too Holy

  Why We Eat Fish Before Meat. Likkutei Torah Behaaloscha Maamar Eim Es Kal Dagei Hayam.